I can’t exactly remember the circumstances, but recently I meant to saying something was ‘like riding a bike’ (meaning it was a skill that would come back to you easily, even if you hadn’t done it in a while), but instead what came out of my mouth was ‘it’s like falling off a bike’. The people I was with all got a good laugh.
But now I’m wondering if ‘falling off a bike’ fits this particular situation better.
It had been a while since I’d used milk paint when I pulled out the Miss Mustard Seed Tricycle to paint my North Pole Bed and Breakfast sign a few weeks back.

That particular project went quite smoothly, although I didn’t really get the chipping that I wanted.
I was painting another of those cupboard door signs at the same time. I followed the same exact prep process with both. I lightly scuff sanded them, and then cleaned them with a TSP substitute (I use the Sunnyside brand from Menards, if anyone is curious).
For the 2nd sign, I pulled out some Sweet Pickins milk paint in a color called In a Pickle. I mixed it up and painted up the 2nd cupboard door. Imagine my consternation when the 2nd one not only chipped, it chipped A LOT.

I’d forgotten just how unpredictable milk paint can be. Frankly, this is why I rarely use it anymore. It can be pretty frustrating to get results like this when it’s not what you wanted. I get much more reliable results with the chalk style paint from Dixie Belle that I use most often.
Also, I want to point out that you can always add the bonding agent to your milk paint which will eliminate the chipping altogether.
That being said, there really is no substitute for the authentically chippy look you can get with straight up milk paint … you just have to be OK with the possibility of wildly varying results.
I have experienced my share of overly chippy milk paint projects in the past, and in one case I ultimately ended up sanding the piece down entirely and starting over with chalk paint (you can find that story starting here, and ending here).
Since I really wanted some chippy-ness on this piece though, I decided to try a couple of tricks to see what I could do with this one. First up I sanded it a little bit more thoroughly, which did remove quite a bit of the chipping paint, and then I painted two more coats of In a Pickle. Once the paint was dry, I still had quite a lot of chipping. So next I vacuumed away all of the loose chips, and then I sealed it with a coat of Rust-Oleum matte spray sealer. Once that dried, I went back in again with another coat of the milk paint over it.
That helped somewhat, but it definitely did not eliminate the chipping entirely.

But at that point I decided this was a level of chipping that I could live with.
After giving the piece another coat of spray sealer, I added a stencil.

This is another one that I ordered from The Stencil Smith. I had to modify it slightly to fit on my cupboard door by leaving the “Picked Fresh Daily” off the top. But otherwise it worked perfectly.
Once again I used my shadowing technique to put a dark shadow behind just the “Garden Herbs” wording.

That is Dixie Belle’s Coffee Bean for the shadow, and Drop Cloth for the 2nd layer.
Once the stenciled paint was dry, I once again sealed the entire piece with the Rust-Oleum spray.

In the end, I’m quite happy with how this turned out, chipping and all.
What do you think? Are you a fan of the chippy look, or are you over it? Or maybe you never were a fan at all? Leave me a comment and let me know.
This garden herbs sign is for sale locally (check my ‘available for local sale‘ page for more details).



































































































Next I layered on some wording from the I.O.D. Label Ephemera transfer.








