To paint, or not to paint?  That is the question.

And it’s one that I often struggle with.

I don’t like to destroy an authentic patina that took decades to develop by painting over it.  In fact, I often cringe a little inside when I see other crafters doing exactly that.

But then again, things almost always sell better for me if I paint them.

And that brings me to ice skates.

Wait, what?  Ice skates?  Surely I’m not losing sleep over whether or not to paint vintage ice skates, am I?

Well, let’s look at some ice skates I’ve shared in the past.

The first skates I ever painted were these pretty pink ice skates back in 2017.

So sweet, right?  Well, here is the before photo of them …

Painting those felt like a bit of a no-brainer.

Flash forward to 2019 when I added a floral re.design with prima transfer to some skates after freshening them up with some of Dixie Belle’s Drop Cloth.

I LOVED how those turned out!

So then I repeated that idea back in 2020 with this pair of skates.

I considered both of those pairs of skates to be your basic outdated 80’s or 90’s ice skates with no vintage value whatsoever, and probably no real practical value as functional ice skates either.

They both looked pretty much like this before I painted them …

But then there are the skates that I really don’t think should be painted, like this pair that my friend Sue sold at one of our Carriage House sales …

I also have this pair of skates in my stash that I used to stage a photo last year.

I changed out the laces for some alphabet twill ribbon, but otherwise left them ‘as is’.

That brings me to my current stash of skates.  I have one pair that I’m not sure I should paint …

They aren’t quite as fabulous as the pair that Sue had, but they do have a certain aged patina that I like.  What do you think?  Should I paint them, or should I leave them alone?

Before you answer that question, let me share another pair from my stash that I recently painted up.

After giving them a good wash with a damp rag and some Dawn dish soap, I gave them a coat of Dixie Belle’s Drop Cloth.  It just took one coat to freshen them up enough to add some transfers.

Then I pulled out the remaining remnants from my Dixie Belle Evergreen and Holly transfer.  I’ve mentioned this transfer quite a few times lately, mainly because it was a limited release for last year and now it can be pretty hard to find (although there are a few still out there).

I had a few bits of holly left from mine, so I decided to use them on the skates.

But I needed to fill in more space, so I also pulled out DB’s Vintage Post transfer.  I used a combination of Vintage Post and Evergreen and Holly together last year on a lock box and I really liked how they worked together.  Once again, they combined beautifully.

In case you’re wondering, I left the opposite side of each skate plain.

I figure most people are going to display these hanging from a sled, or maybe hanging in front of a wreath on the door.  In other words, only one side of each skate will really be visible so I didn’t want to waste my resources (ie. transfers).

Once I had all of the transfers applied, I added a coat of Dixie Belle’s Big Mama’s Butta over the skates to add some protection.  That being said, they would not be terribly weather proof.  I would not display them outside in an unprotected area.  You could put them on a covered porch though.  The cold won’t hurt them, but too much moisture might.

While I was working on painting and applying transfers, I had the original laces for these skates soaking in some OxyClean.  But when I pulled them out I realized that they weren’t really salvageable.  They were quite frayed, and they also had some rust stains that wouldn’t come out.

So I decided to add some velvet ribbon as laces.

I found some wonderfully frayed green velvet ribbon at Hobby Lobby that was perfect for the job.

After a bit of hesitation, I have decided to sell this pair of skates (I was really tempted to keep them!), but I can always make another pair for myself if I just can’t live without them.

So be sure to check my ‘available for local sale‘ page for more details if you’re interested (sorry, I don’t ship my items so you have to be local).  I’ll be bringing these into the shop when I get back from visiting my mom, so speak up soon if you want them!

Thank you to Dixie Belle Paint Co for providing the paint, Big Mama’s Butta and transfers used on these skates.